and the new phone is...

a Droid. Phone number remains the same, though I may play some Google Voice games at some point.

After an hour or so of fiddling around with it:

Good: that screen is very nice. Scrolls really quickly, and stops on your thumb. Voice quality is excellent. Feels solid, although I always expect a slide keyboard to be spring loaded, which this one is not. Dense. About the same weight as my previous phone, a Palm Treo 700P. The browser is good, after I futzed with the settings.
Connecting to WiFi or 3G or 2G data is all seamless.

Bad: Google knows everything.

Ugly: the case is kinda angular.

and the new phone is...

a Droid. Phone number remains the same, though I may play some Google Voice games at some point.

After an hour or so of fiddling around with it:

Good: that screen is very nice. Scrolls really quickly, and stops on your thumb. Voice quality is excellent. Feels solid, although I always expect a slide keyboard to be spring loaded, which this one is not. Dense. About the same weight as my previous phone, a Palm Treo 700P. The browser is good, after I futzed with the settings.
Connecting to WiFi or 3G or 2G data is all seamless.

Bad: Google knows everything.

Ugly: the case is kinda angular.